thing Fantasy literature has always proudly stood for is the truth.
Tearing down lies and deceptions to face the facts no matter how hard or
twisted they may be; no matter how much grief they may cause, no matter
what forces may at best try to tell you that you are wrong and at worst
threaten you and those you love with death for daring to utter a truth
that does not match their worldview and/or agenda."Truth is the fire that fetches thunder." - Diana Wynne Jones
|"It tells you the truth. As for how to read it, |
you'll have to learn by yourself."
no such thing as 'one, true way'; the only answers worth having are the
ones you find for yourself; leave the world better than you found it.
Love, freedom, and the chance to do some good -- they're the things
worth living and dying for, and if you aren't willing to die for the
things worth living for, you might as well turn in your membership in
the human race." - Mercedes Lackey
"To crooked eyes truth may wear a wry face." - J.R.R. Tolkien
you understand that you must always fail, as long as your goal is not
truth, but guidance? That as long as you seek dragons around you, you
will never become the dragon within you?" - Sarkhan Vol
Such is the nature, the wisdom and morality
of the Fantastic, but within all that is something more. Something that
hits the highest peak, and is best summarized by Terry Brooks and
Cadvan of Lirigon: "Love supplies a kind of strength that can withstand even death." and "To love is never wrong. It may be disastrous; it may never be possible; it may be the deepest agony. But it is never wrong."
Where am I going with all this? That at the heart of Fantasy lies
self-acceptance. Often this manifests with characters coming to terms
with burdensome destinies, or accepting that they are not who they were
when the journey began and trying find a path forwards. But, more than
anything else, it supports love – both self-love and loving another. Hence, to cut to the chase, Fantasy literature supports the LGBTQ+ community.
Sadly, however, there are scarcely more LGBTQ characters than female sages
in the genre, making it an issue that Fantasy needs to tackle just as
heartily as it has cross-eyed monster that is sexism. Now I can hear you
saying, "Uh, Ian, you can Google LGBTQ Fantasy and get whole lists of books with solid
and strong LGBTQ protagonists." Alas, therein lies my exact point. You
have to look them up. I breathe Fantasy and am always looking for new
books and there is seldom a method in my search save High, moral, Fantasy that is unique if possible. As I said in my Race in Fantasy
page, when I am in a bookstore searching for new Fantasies I just pull
out whatever looks interesting, read the back and/or inside cover, and
if it passes muster I give it a try. How many of those are LGBTQ Fantasies? Precious few are even on the shelves, and those that are lean heavily into being LGBTQ. Where is the issue? In short, LGBTQ Fantasy should not be a sub-genre; rather, Queer
characters should be as common as books with female protagonists. Hence
should not have to look them up. Once Fantasy was male dominated and one
had to search for ones with female leads. Now Fantasy literature has
more woman/girl protagonists than otherwise and does an excellent job
skewering sexism. One does not have to Google strong girl characters,
nor is the fact that they are girls made great issue of in marketing the
book. That the character is a girl is just a part of the story, part of
their character just as much as a boy being a boy is. Harry
Potter is a boy and Luna Lovegood a girl. Important facts, yes, but
hardly needing a banner to announce it nor for a reader to understand
what it means.
Meaning a gay/lesbian romance should be no more remarkable than a 'typical'
boy-girl one. And is that not the goal? To normalize being LGBTQ. In my Females in Fantasy page, I say, "Is
this not the goal? A world free of gender biases and norms may seem
alien and yet, when written, appears as nothing less than utterly
normal. Girl? Boy? Man? Woman? We are all Human and that is the great
lesson Fantasy literature so often seeks to convey and rejoice in." Well, the same stands for being LGBTQ. Bisexual? Heterosexual (straight)? Homosexual? We
are all Human and that is the great lesson Fantasy literature so often
seeks to convey and rejoice in. It should not matter and thus, when I go
to a bookstore, pick a book and begin reading it, I should find gay or lesbian romance between characters no less often than heterosexual
ones. It need not be a sub-genre, as most good Fantasy has romance even
when it is not classified as Romantic Fantasy. Which is another reason I
have not read much LGBTQ Fantasy. What reason is that? The same as why I
generally avoid Romantic Fantasy: while I have nothing against and in
fact very much enjoy romances in Fantasy literature, I prefer it when
they supplement the overall plot instead of dominate it to the point
where it feels like the rest of the story is simply to drive and add
tension to the romance. Which is what I think Queer Fantasy as a sub-genre has become, Homosexual Romantic Fantasy in effect. Not that there is anything wrong with that per se, as books like Isabel Sterling's These Witches Don't Burn series are thrill-rides
but, again, having homosexual characters in Fantasy literature should
be as unremarkable and unremarked upon as girl-boy romances. It should
supplement the overall plot instead of dominating it.
I read books which feature such, or at least heard of and plan to read
them? Blessedly and absolutely yes. Here is picture
of Vanyel Ashkevron from The Last Herald Mage Trilogy by Mercedes Lackey, and not only is Vanyel the
main protagonist but also a legendary figure often spoken of by
Mercedes Lackey's other characters in the subsequent centuries and
series. Oh, and he is gay. Indeed, I think Mercedes Lackey captures the future of homosexuality in Fantasy because she normalizes it. Her The Heralds of Valdemar, Vows and Honor, Mage Winds and Mage Storms in addition to The Last Herald Mage Trilogy all
feature LGBTQ characters. Tarma shena Tale'sedrin is asexual, Warrl is
physically asexual but male-minded, Vanyel is homosexual as is...well, I
would rather avoid giving spoilers, so I will just say that one of
his also preternaturally handsome descendants is gay as well. To say
nothing of plenty of important secondary characters and minor characters
who are never named yet we learn are homosexual due to the
natural arch of the story revealing that knowledge. At this point it is
worth noting that Mercedes
Lackey's iconic Valdemar books was one of the first to feature Queer
characters as heroes. Something of an irony really, that since then Queer Fantasy has risen as a subset/sub-genre of Romantic Fantasy and yet Lackey's
normalization remains, again and in my opinion, the key to its future.
For, and here is the key point, none of her aforementioned series are
classified as LGBTQ Fantasy (with the possible exception of The Last Herald Mage,
possible because I have seen many lists omitting it). Why? Because
Vanyel being gay is not the point of the story. It is important, to be
sure, for the Kingdom of Valdemar was back then far more homophobic and
his family gave him worlds of grief over being gay, but a Herald's duty
is to protect the Kingdom and Valdemar needed Vanyel to save it. That is
the prime plot, how Vanyel
Ashkevron became a the most powerful, famous, and important Herald who
ever lived. I think you get the picture. In short, in order to best
combat hatred towards the LQBTQ community, Fantasy literature must not
create a sub-genre around it but rather internalize/write Queer
characters in existing ones. Indeed, Lackey's books are frequently cited
by the LGBTQ community as inspirational or comforting influences on
their lives as LGBTQ characters are depicted as both good and bad and
range over all aspects of life without engaging in blatant stereotypes. In fact, Radar Pictures is bringing of The Last Herald-Mage trilogy to the TV screen, and the importance of adapting a fantasy series featuring an openly gay protagonist is not lost on producer Kit Williamson: “Vanyel
in The Last Herald Mage series was one of the first gay characters I
encountered, and as a recently out 16-year-old I can’t stress enough the
impact that these books had on me. The Valdemar series was far ahead of
its time in the portrayal of LGBTQ characters, and Lackey’s writing
afforded them a level of depth and complexity that is still very rare,
especially in genre storytelling."
very rare, especially in genre storytelling. My point exactly.
Fortunately, rare is not nowhere and I can give other examples of
exemplary Fantasy which gives Queer characters proper and normalizing
literary treatment: The Graceling Realms by Kristin Cashore and House of Hollow by Krystal Sutherland. While other books dip the toe in. Robert Jordan's The Wheel of Time features some minor homosexual characters in its huge cast, as does, though I am loathe to mention him, George R. R. Martin's A Song of Ice and Fire in characters such as the apparently bisexual Prince Oberyn Martell and the gay Jon Connington.
|Alesha, Who Smiles at Death|
I can hear you saying, "Ian, this is fascinating to hear, but you do
know that LGBTQ is about more than one's sexuality, right?" Naturally I
know, which is why this page is not finished yet and why I am
introducing you to Alesha, Who Smiles at Death and Narset, the Enlightened Master and Transcendent. Yes, I know that Alesha and Narset are not even book characters but rather ones from the card game Magic: the Gathering, but that does not make them less strong, worthy, or important in regards to what, to who, they represent. Alesha is transgender (she was born a boy), and Narset is on
the autism spectrum, but these traits are not roles they play as opposed to
who they are. Their roles being leaders both figuratively and literally (in
one timeline anyway) and the pride of their respective Clans. But their
stories do not revolve around being transgender or autistic. Naturally they
had to deal with these things and the obstacles they presented, but
there is much more to both of them and I love their stories.
sadly, transgender and autistic characters are even less common than
Queer ones, lacking even a sub-genre to call their own. Indeed,
"autistic fantasy" is actually a medical term describing how an
individual deals with external and environmental stressors by
daydreaming and retreating into an inner fantasy world. As J.R.R.
Tolkien says, "I have claimed that Escape is one of the main
functions of fairy-stories, and since I do not disapprove of them, it is
plain that I do not accept the tone of scorn or pity with which
“Escape” is now so often used: a tone for which the uses of the word
outside literary criticism give no warrant at all. Why should a man be
scorned if, finding himself in prison, he tries to get out and go home?
Or if, when he cannot do so, he thinks and talks about other topics than
jailers and prison-walls? The world outside has not become less real
because the prisoner cannot see it. In using escape in this way the
critics have chosen the wrong word, and, what is more, they are
confusing, not always by sincere error, the Escape of the Prisoner with
the Flight of the Deserter." Do you not love how a medical term can be seen in a new light with a Tolkien quote? I know the term is valid, but the strict definition
sounds similar what a non-autistic but very imaginative person does
naturally. Anyway, back on topic, those on the autism spectrum are vastly
underrepresented in Fantasy literature to the degree that, in all my
vast reading, Narset is the only character I can point to. Sort of.
Actually, I know for a fact that the justly famed and phenomenally
popular The Stormlight Archive by Brandon Sanderson has several
characters on the spectrum, but as I have not read it yet (though I plan
to!) I cannot speak of it further save that Sanderson is doing exactly
what needs to be done. That, by including them, he leads the Fantasy
vanguard in fighting for all inclusiveness and understanding. Now I
personally am not LGBTQ, and I reveal this for the same reason I say or
reveal anything, to make a point – which is that fighting for LGBTQ inclusiveness should not only be no less important to those who are not as those who are, it should be especially important. Yes, especially, because while the
LGBTQ are fighting to be included, those such as I who are not must be
the includers (which may not be a word, but should be). That puts the
battle on our soil. Hence it is our duty to proactively include them to
the best of our literary ability in the manner I have described.
sexism the cross-eyed monster that Fantasy literature has basically if
not utterly dealt with (for the lack of female Gandalf figures still needs
rectifying), so I shall name homophobia – along with all other anti-LGBTG+ sentiments and
prejudice against the autistic – the blind monster that the Fantasy genre
is at this moment fighting and slowly but steadily besting. For it is
said that the arc of the universe bends towards justice, which means
that truth always prevails. A sentiment that is backed by history as
pointed out by Mahatma Gandhi: "There
have been tyrants and murderers, and for a time, they can seem
invincible, but in the end, they always fall. Think of it--always.” Well, anti-LGBTG+ sentiments
are tyrannical by definition since trying to tell other people who they
are and/or whom they are allowed to love is despotic to a level Sauron would
approve of; and Fantasy literature, guided by the Spirit of Tolkien and
the will of countless authors since, has now and always will oppose such
"The young must grow old,
Whilst old ones grow older,
And cowards will shrink,
As the bold grow bolder.
Courage may blossom in quiet hearts,
For who can tell where bravery starts?
Truth is a song, oft lying unsung,
Some mother bird, protecting her young,
Those who lay down their lives for friends,
The echo rolls onward, it seldom ends.
Who never turned and ran, but stayed?
This is a warrior born, not made!
Living in peace, aye many a season,
Calm in life and sound in reason,
'Til evil arrives, a wicked horde,
Driving a warrior to pick up his sword,
The challenger rings then, straight and fair,
Justice is with us, beware. Beware!"